Our Gospel this night begins: ‘In those days a decree went out from Caesar Augustus that all the world should be registered.’ (Luke 2:1) Augustus was the Roman Emperor who was the first to encourage a cult to deify his name and reign. Ancient inscriptions identify Augustus as god, son of god, and saviour, and they associate with him peace, hope and good news. All of these things were applied to Jesus in the angelic announcement to the shepherds. (Luke 2:10-12) The angel identifies Jesus as the Messiah-Lord and Saviour. ‘Messiah’ means God’s anointed king. ‘Lord’ is the standard way the Hebrew Scripture referred to the name of God: YHWH. As ‘Messiah-Lord,’ then, Jesus is not simply the Messiah of the Lord, but the Messiah who is the Lord. (C.f.: Luke 23:2; Ezekiel 34:15) ‘Saviour’ was a title that Augustus repeatedly used to promote himself as ‘saviour of the common folk’ and ‘saviour of the world.’ As saviour, Augustus pushed himself as the one who inaugurated a new and propitious age of peace, order and prosperity, thus fulfilling the longings of all humanity. The angel’s announcement is a direct challenge to the then prevailing Roman political-theology, right here at the beginning of Luke’s Gospel, and with the real good news for humanity being contained not in any decree of the Emperor, but in this divine proclamation from heaven. We will see this juxtaposition of Emperor and Messiah-Lord once more, when for his last Passover, Jesus enters into Jerusalem, that other city of David, riding on a donkey, while on the other side of Zion’s Mount comes the Roman Governor riding on a horse flanked by bannered troops and a show of force, and where the consequence of this challenge will be played out. (Luke 19:28ff. C.f.: John 10:11-12; 15:13)

However, the setting and the characters of this night’s story are all wrong. Our Messiah-Lord comes to us not as the all-powerful King, but as a poor and helpless little child … one least in the kingdom of the men of his day. (C.f.: Mark 9:34-37; Matthew 11:11; Galatians 4:1-2; John 18:33ff) He is found not in some fine palace where the powerful gather, but in a mean hovel, a stable. (C.f.: Matthew 11:8) And the news of his coming is proclaimed not to the rich and powerful, but to poor shepherds out in the fields, those whom you would never trust but more probably despise, those you would not dream of inviting into your own home, those whose testimony would never be accepted in any court of law. And yet, it is these poor and despised common folk who know more where to find him. (Luke 2:15-16) For us good folk who await his coming (C.f.: Luke 2:25), we must know that he is not to be found in palaces. (C.f.: Matthew 2:2) But rather, as a starting point, that to find him we need to go out to the peripheries where the more unfortunates among us are to be found, as Pope Francis keeps urging us. For as the Christmas story shows, this is where the Christ, Emmanuel, God-with-us, is more surely to be found. (C.f.: Matthew 2:4-5; 18:20; 25:37-40)

And yet we resist reaching out to these people, and we do not want to go there. And so, we look for ways to soften and dilute the call of Christmas. If we look at depictions of the Nativity, we see that it has all been moved upmarket: better clothes, a better class of visitor who bring rich gifts and who are brought right into the centre leaving the poor shepherds outside, and the stable is now more substantial, more palace-like and clean, with the animals kept in their proper place away from the centre … though the Child is lying in their manger, in their feeding trough. The whole scene is all now much more court-like, with the Christ-child now being born more in our midst, not out on the margins, and he is now more enthroned on the manger with all us worthies fittingly bowing down before him (C.f.: Matthew 23:5-7); now he is really our Saviour, one of us, and we can go on keeping all those ‘awful people’ at a distance, as we have always done.

Yet: Can we not see that our God is also the God of those poor and unfortunates on the peripheries, and so, to take the next step to admit and claim our bond with them? Is it really too much for us that ours is a God for all? (C.f.: Luke 1:58) Yet, this is what he is. As St Paul puts it: ‘There is now neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is no male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.’ (Galatians 3:28) ‘Or is God the God of Jews only? Is he not the God of Gentiles also? Yes, of Gentiles also, since God is one’ (Romans 3:29-30) … and we could ask a similar questions of the slave and the free (c.f.: Rule of St Benedict [RB] 2:18), and of the male and the female, as well. All our distinctions — whether they be based on race, gender, wealth, education, or just simply on the have’s and the have not’s — all are now undone. And we, who have been busy cultivating these distinctions to make sure that we can differentiate ourselves from them, are left wondering: ‘Then what advantage has the Jew?’ (Romans 3:1) Does our having have to have about it an exclusiveness that only allows me to see myself as being better than them? Or, is it more that we need such an advantage over others? To admit this should humble us. For, as St Benedict puts it: ‘Those who needs less should thank God and not be sad. And whoever needs more should be humble about his weaknesses and not gloat over the mercy shown him.’ (RB 34:3-4) In truth, those out there on the margins really are the stronger. For though they have little choice in the matter, they can and do survive without such advantages.

And yet, our having need not be a problem. Those out on the edges do it tough; life shouldn’t be just about surviving, but more about living. They have not enough, while the more well off have more than enough. We who would acknowledge the Christ, need to learn to be generous, need to learn to share. (Acts 2:44-45) We need to recognize that the ‘advantage’ we have is but a blessing, something we have received, a gift; it is not ours by right, and we may have it only for a time and a perhaps short time at that. (Psalm 39:6; 49:10, 17) We need to learn to share our good fortune, while we still have it … and have it to share (C.f.: RB 72:7; Mark 10:21): the advantage we have is not something that makes us better, but something that can enable us to share. Jesus commands us: “Love one another as I have loved you.” (John 13:34) Jesus gave his all to us; we must learn to do the same (John 15:13) — we must learn to give our all, not just to those we love, but also to those we don’t much care for … including all those ‘awful people’ out there on the fringes. (C.f.: Mark 12:43-44; Romans 5:8; Matthew 25:40) For as Jesus put it: “For if you love those who love you, what reward do you have? Do not even the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet only your brothers, what more are you doing than others? Do not even the Gentiles do the same?” (Matthew 5:46-47) When we have learned to love as Jesus did, then we too, might come and bring our gifts and offer them, as we bow down and do our homage to our Messiah-Lord, the God-who-is-with-us, the God in our gathering. (C.f.: Matthew 2:11; 18:20; Luke 10:27-28; John 13:35; Acts 4:34-35; 1 Corinthians 11:20-21; RB 72:11-12)

By Dom Steele Hartmann OCSO